On a domestic academic forum for analytic number theory.
At three o’clock that afternoon, a post tagged with "Yan University," "Li Dong," and "Li Clan Conjecture" was pushed to the front page.
The original post was very short, just a segment of meeting minutes shared in a small group chat by one of Fu Chen’s doctoral students.
"It is advised that everyone stop working on the two main lines of the Li Clan Conjecture, including its weak form and low-dimensional special cases."
The comments section instantly exploded.
"Li Dong is basically shutting the door on everyone in the country working in this field."
"He proposed the conjecture himself, and now he’s telling others not to prove it? What kind of move is that?"
"To put it bluntly, Weber’s GL(3) paper is already up on the Annals. The candidates for the Fields Medal after next are pretty much set."
"For Li Dong to come out now and tell everyone to stop... isn’t that in poor taste?"
"Conjectures are meant to be proven by everyone. The Poincaré Conjecture took a hundred years from its proposal in 1904 until Perelman’s proof. Countless people threw themselves at it in the interim. Who’s ever heard of the person who proposed a conjecture turning around and telling others not to prove it?"
"This past year he’s been dabbling in solar physics one moment and enzymes the next. Maybe he can’t keep up with the Li Clan Conjecture anymore, and he’s afraid someone will beat him to the punch, so he’s just putting up a smokescreen?"
Of course, there were also dissenting opinions.
"Have the posters above not seen the part about principal triangulation that Li Dong presented today?"
"How did Milnor’s counterexample come about back then? All of you who are constantly talking about how mathematics is about scaling new heights should go back and read your history."
"To be even more blunt, has everyone forgotten about Jiang Yubai? That single step forward his research group spent over a decade trying to make—didn’t it become completely meaningless the moment Li Dong’s universality paper came out? And the path Professor Wang and the others followed, the one for discrepancy ≤ 3, didn’t it also turn to ash? Have you all really forgotten?"
After this comment was posted, the thread went quiet for a moment.
The next person to reply had a different tone.
"So, you’re saying Li Dong’s words today carry the same meaning?"
"I’m not saying they definitely do."
"But the cautionary tale is right there for all to see. Back then, a lot of people also thought Jiang Yubai’s research group was on a solid path. And what was the result?"
"..."
"The person who proposes a conjecture wants it to be proven more than anyone else—unless he himself has seen something that others haven’t yet."
This comment was upvoted to the second-highest position.
Someone replied below it.
"How do you know he’s seen something?"
"I’m guessing."
A wave of laughter followed in the replies.
But some people fell silent.
Those who were silent opened the files on their computers—the dozens of unsubmitted preprints, the stacks of drafts where the discrepancy index couldn’t be pushed any higher—and their hearts sank.
’What if Li Dong is telling the truth?’
No one dared to think further, but they still wouldn’t stop.
Because they needed to graduate, to get promotions.
Even if the Li Clan Conjecture really did need to be restated in the end, that would be a matter for decades later.
For now, with the draft on low-discrepancy GL(3) in hand, if they could submit it, they would. If they could get it into a Q1 journal, they would.
...
「On the other side of the Pacific Ocean.」
In an ordinary house in a suburb of Los Angeles.
Terence Tao had just returned from his office at the University of California. He took off his scarf as he walked in and then unlocked his phone.
The first notification that popped up was a quote featured on the homepage of the math community MathOverflow.
"It is advised that everyone stop working on the two main lines of the Li Clan Conjecture, including its weak form and low-dimensional special cases."
The source was an internal meeting memo from the Yan University School of Mathematics, which had already been translated into English.
Terence Tao stared at the memo, somewhat surprised.
He sat down on the sofa, thought for a moment, and made a call.
"Terry?"
The voice on the other end held a note of surprise.
Terence Tao got straight to the point.
"Old Su, did you see it?"
Su Qiwang didn’t ask what "it" was.
Because he had just stopped writing on page sixty-one of his draft on the statistical threshold for numerical verification in the high-discrepancy case of GL(n).
Su Qiwang was silent for a few seconds.
"I saw it."
"What do you think?"
Terence Tao asked.
"What about you?"
Su Qiwang asked back.
Terence Tao chuckled.
"I asked first."
"Alright then."
Su Qiwang said slowly.
"The kid... he’s probably serious."
"So, are you going to stop?"
Terence Tao asked again.
There was silence on Su Qiwang’s end.
The chair professor of Brown University’s Department of Applied Mathematics had spent almost the entire last six months focused on the high-discrepancy case of GL(n).
The six PhD students and three postdocs in his research group were all working on this main line.
The path Su Qiwang was taking involved using Li Dong’s set of criteria for zero-pair correlation as a probe, testing it in the general, unrestricted e_v case of GL(n) to see if a stable numerical boundary could be found at a certain discrepancy index.
The entire underlying logic of this path was built on the version of the Li Clan Conjecture that was presumed to be final and correct.
If the final version of the Li Clan Conjecture was different from what everyone currently believed...
...his last six months of work might have to be redone from scratch.
But...
Su Qiwang finally let out a laugh.
"I’m not stopping."
"Why not?"
Terence Tao asked.
"What are we after, when we do research?" Su Qiwang said.
"Isn’t it for the intellectual satisfaction? Even if the Li Clan Conjecture turns out to be different from what we all expect, just as the kid said, by continuing our work, we can at least understand exactly why the path was wrong."
Terence Tao didn’t seem surprised. He just laughed.
"That makes sense."
The two chatted for a few more moments about other things before hanging up.
...
「Ontario, Canada.」
Inside a log cabin by a lake.
The fire in the hearth had burned low. Embers flared up occasionally before dying down again.
Robert Langlands sat in an armchair before the fire.
In front of him lay an English excerpt printed from an email.
"It is advised that everyone stop working on the two main lines of the Li Clan Conjecture, including its weak form and low-dimensional special cases."
Langlands looked at it for a long time.
He didn’t think Li Dong was putting up a smokescreen.
"He must have seen it."
"Seen the silhouette of the Gangling Mansion."
Wind stirred across the lake outside, and the window frame of the cabin rattled softly.
...
「Princeton, third floor of the mathematics department building.」
Marvin Clark’s office was not large, but it was tidy.
On his desk was a photo with the former director of the NSF’s mathematics division, and next to it, a photo with the current department chair at a Thanksgiving dinner.
At that moment, the screen of the computer in Clark’s hands also displayed Li Dong’s recommendation.
He read it over and over three times, then turned to a young man in his early thirties beside him.
"Weber."
"What are your thoughts on Professor Li Dong’s statement today?"
Weber smiled and shook his head.
"Professor Li Dong is the one who proposed the Li Clan Conjecture, that’s correct."
"But I don’t think he has truly recognized the essence of the Li Clan Conjecture."
Clark raised an eyebrow but didn’t reply.
If it had been anyone else, he might not have believed them, but this was...
Elias Weber, one of the youngest professors in Princeton’s mathematics department, at thirty-one years old.
The number of people in Princeton’s history who had attained a full professorship in their early thirties could be counted on one hand.
Weber was not widely famous. His most public achievement was the paper published in the *Mathematical Annals* two months ago on a weakened criterion for the zero-pair correlation function of automorphic L-functions in the low-discrepancy interval for the GL(3) case.
Just by looking at the title, an outsider could easily lump it together with other work on GL(3).
In fact, many posts on the forum were comparing Weber’s paper with the research line of Jiang Yubai’s group from back then. Both were on GL(3), both dealt with low discrepancy, and both touched upon local-global compatibility.
But the two were on completely different levels.
What Jiang Yubai had tried to push back then was advancing the discrepancy index for GL(3) from e_v=2 to e_v=3.
To put it plainly, it was taking half a step forward along the path of pure algebra, on that main line—an incremental advance.
That path was later smashed to bits by Li Dong’s universality paper, turning completely to ash.
Weber’s paper was different.
What he did was provide a closed characterization, one that could be numerically verified, of the correspondence between the zero-pair correlation structure and the Langlands local-global compatibility within the entire GL(3) layer.
To put it another way.
If the Langlands Program stopped at GL(3)...
...then Weber’s paper would be equivalent to putting the final capstone on the entire Langlands Program.
But that was on one condition.
That the Langlands Program really did end at GL(3).
And the words Li Dong spoke today in that lecture hall at Yan University...
"The version of the Li Clan Conjecture that will ultimately be proven might not be the same one everyone thinks it is."
...that was a goddamn direct shot at Weber.
Weber looked at Clark.
He didn’t offer much of an explanation, because he felt Clark wouldn’t be able to understand his ideas.
Among his peers, only Li Dong was qualified to debate him on this level. Of course, Terence Tao could be counted as one, too.
Clark didn’t mind, because he knew certain things about this Weber—confidential matters—so he trusted Weber’s judgment.
"Alright."
"Then let’s not pay him any mind. We’ll each focus on our own upcoming projects. Don’t let his words disrupt our rhythm."
He thought for a moment, then added.
"Oh, right, Penrose will be back soon, too. I hear he got quite close to Li Dong over there. When he returns to Princeton, you should find some time to get closer to him."
When Weber heard the name "Penrose," a flash of impatience crossed his face. He had no particular fondness for old professors like Penrose who were obsessed with cozying up to young people from the East.
But he nodded anyway.
"Of course, Professor Clark."

Comments

Loading...