Once everyone had entered and filled the lecture hall, Li Dong slowly walked up to the stage.
As he walked onto the stage, he was reminded of that room in G?ttingen, of the discussion between those three titans.
Klein’s words: "I’ve always felt that the part we owed from our time on invariant theory shouldn’t have stopped at commutative groups."
And Noether’s mention of, "Equivalence classes, quotient objects, unicity—all of these will have to be rewritten."
All of this faintly overlapped with the hazy outline he had envisioned.
Li Dong stood with his back to the blackboard and cleared his throat.
"The crowd today..."
"Is bigger than I expected."
"So I haven’t prepared much. I hope you’ll bear with me."
Someone in the audience immediately called back.
"No worries, no worries!"
"We’re the ones who crashed the party!"
"Just speak your mind!"
Li Dong nodded.
"My teachers and my supervisors are in the room today, so I won’t beat around the bush."
In the audience, Tian Gang gave him a slight smile, and Liu Ruochuan nodded at him as well.
Penrose, however, remained expressionless, but his eyes never left Li Dong.
Gong Qi sat off to the side, holding a thermos, his expression relatively relaxed.
Li Dong continued.
"Today, I mainly want to talk about one thing, which is to offer everyone a piece of advice."
Everyone in the audience listened with rapt attention.
Ever since Li Dong established this research group, he himself had rarely made any public statements.
Over the past year, everyone had seen the steady stream of results from the PhDs and associate professors under him, while he, the leader, had practically vanished for the entire year.
So today, everyone wanted to see just what advice this young man, the proposer of Li’s Conjecture, would give them.
Li Dong didn’t bother with any more buildup.
"My advice to everyone..."
"Is to stop chipping away at the weak form of Li’s Conjecture, and stop working on its low-dimensional special cases."
"In other words, it’s best not to touch the two main lines of inquiry for Li’s Conjecture at all."
The moment he said this, the lecture hall fell silent.
Whispers started to break out in the back few rows.
"...What did he just say?"
"He’s telling us not to work on the main lines?"
"Is he telling us not to work on Li’s Conjecture?"
"He proposed the conjecture himself, and now he’s telling us not to prove it?"
The murmuring spread from the back of the hall to the front.
Li Dong stood on the stage without interrupting them. He knew this kind of reaction was normal.
Historically, whenever a major conjecture was proposed, the number of people working on it only grew over time.
From the time the Poincaré Conjecture was proposed in the 1890s until Perelman proved it, for over a hundred years, the most brilliant mathematicians in the world were all chipping away at its low-dimensional cases, its geometrization aspect, and its Ricci flow form.
Who had ever heard of the person who proposed a conjecture turning around and telling everyone not to work on it?
The voices in the audience grew louder.
"What does Professor Li mean by this..."
"Is he afraid we’ll snatch his Fields Medal?"
"Weber’s paper on GL(3) came out two months ago. He’s already got his eye on the one after next."
The voice wasn’t loud, but it was exceptionally jarring.
Li Dong listened from the stage, showing no reaction. He knew there would be criticism like this.
Just then, a man stood up from his seat in the third row, on the right.
He was a middle-aged man in his forties, dressed in a dark gray suit, with a Shuimu school pin on his chest.
Li Dong recognized him. Chen Zhiyuan, a professor at Tsinghua University’s Center for Mathematical Sciences, one of the first people in the country to start research on Li’s Conjecture.
It was widely acknowledged in the field that he was stuck just one step behind Weber’s line of research; another half-step and he might have been able to cross it.
"Professor Li."
His tone was polite, but his brows were furrowed.
"With all due respect, I don’t quite understand the advice you’ve just given."
"Historically, major conjectures have always required countless people to explore every unknown path, one by one, and to illuminate every corner hidden in the mist, so that future generations may travel further down a relatively smooth road."
"Now, with a single sentence, you want to drive away everyone on this road. What is the meaning of this?"
More than half the people in the lecture hall nodded in agreement.
Even the associate professors in Li Dong’s own research group couldn’t help but turn their heads to look at him.
Li Dong let out a soft sigh.
He didn’t answer immediately. Instead, he turned and wrote a single term on the blackboard.
Hauptvermutung.
"Professor Chen, let me first ask everyone a question. How many of you have heard of this?"
The people below looked at each other in confusion.
In the back rows, a few people who looked like students gently shook their heads.
In the front row, however, Tian Gang showed a thoughtful expression.
Seeing that no one was speaking, Li Dong continued.
"In 1908, it was independently proposed by Steinitz and Tietze. It studied a very natural problem."
"Given a manifold and two different triangulations, can these two triangulations be refined into a common triangulation?"
"This is the Hauptvermutung, the Main Triangulation Conjecture."
"After this conjecture was proposed, from the 1920s to the 1950s, a period of thirty years, topologists all over the world were chipping away at it."
"Around 1925, Rado was the first to prove the two-dimensional case."
"In 1952, Moise proved the three-dimensional case."
"Both proofs were considered textbook-level work at the time."
"And because of this, both Rado and Moise became famous."
"People in this field at the time generally believed one thing: since it held true for two and three dimensions, proving it for higher dimensions, even if not possible at the moment, was only a matter of time."
"And then what happened?"
Li Dong paused on the stage.
"In 1961, the Milnor Dragon appeared, a high-dimensional counterexample."
"The Hauptvermutung, in high dimensions, is false."
"The entire conjecture... collapsed."
A few of the students in the audience let out an involuntary "Ah!" before quickly stifling themselves.
Many people in the audience were starting to react.
Tian Gang let out a soft "hmm."
Li Dong continued.
"The proofs for two and three dimensions were not wrong in themselves."
"If you look at those two proofs today, they are still correct."
"But once Milnor’s counterexample came out, the entire topology community’s view on the Hauptvermutung changed."
"Everyone had originally thought that the set of piecewise-linear methods from the two and three-dimensional proofs could be pushed all the way up; it was just technically difficult."
"Only after the counterexample appeared did everyone realize it wasn’t a matter of technical difficulty at all. There are fundamental geometric obstructions in high dimensions that you just don’t feel in two or three dimensions."
"In other words, for the thirty years prior, everyone thought they were walking along a main road. Every time they proved a low-dimensional case, they thought they were one step closer to the summit."
"Looking back after the counterexample, that so-called main road was a dead end."
At this point, Li Dong turned back to the board and wrote another line beneath the word "Hauptvermutung".
Li’s Conjecture—is the same.
After he finished writing, he gently placed the chalk back in the tray and turned around.
"This is what I wanted to tell everyone today."
"For the main line of inquiry of Li’s Conjecture, there is only one meaningful way to proceed: to prove it completely, turning Li’s Conjecture into Li’s Theorem."
"Until it becomes a theorem, all the low-dimensional special cases, all the weak forms with restricted ramification indices, are just guesses—guesses as to where this main line will ultimately lead."
"Guess right, and these low-dimensional proofs become stepping stones. Guess wrong, and they just become isolated rocks."
"This is something that has happened repeatedly throughout history."
At this, Li Dong’s gaze fell back on Chen Zhiyuan.
"Professor Chen, I have read your previous papers. They are technically beautiful."
"But I’ll be honest with you. I know in my heart that the final, correct version of Li’s Conjecture might not be the same version that everyone thinks it is right now."
"There will be adjustments."
"All current results based on weak forms with restricted ramification indices will probably have to be restated at that time."
"In the process of restating them, flaws will appear in the original proofs. Not mathematical flaws, but definitional ones—flaws that only become apparent when placed within the new framework."
"I can’t prove this to you right now, because Li’s Conjecture has not yet become a theorem."
"But I am confident."
"And that is why I’m offering this advice."
After Li Dong finished this speech, the entire lecture hall became unnervingly quiet.

Comments

Loading...